Selective Wave Soldering: Tackling Real-Time Performance and Safety Redundancy Challenges in Industrial Robot Control PCBs

technologyNovember 3, 2025 12 min read

Selective Wave SolderingSelective SolderingTHTSMTFirst Article Inspection (FAI)Flying probe testTraceability/MESDFM/DFT/DFA reviewFixture design (ICT/FCT)

As a testing and certification engineer responsible for ICT/FCT, CE certification, and coating processes, I fully understand the stringent requirements for industrial robot control PCBs. These systems must not only handle high-speed real-time data but also possess extremely high safety redundancy. In this context, Selective Wave Soldering technology becomes the key to connecting high-density SMT components with high-reliability through-hole (THT) devices (such as connectors and power components). It directly determines the product's electrical performance, mechanical strength, and long-term reliability.

Industrial robot control boards are typically complex mixed-technology circuit boards, featuring both precision BGAs and QFNs, as well as THT connectors that must withstand high currents and mechanical stress. Traditional wave soldering cannot meet the demands of such high-density, localized soldering, while manual soldering struggles to ensure consistency and quality. Therefore, the precisely controlled Selective Wave Soldering process has become the core manufacturing step to ensure the final product's quality and reliability. This article will focus on this critical process, exploring the key points of quality control throughout the entire workflow, from design and testing to mass production.

DFM/DFT/DFA Review: Ensuring the Success of Selective Wave Soldering from the Source

Any successful manufacturing process begins with excellent design. For Selective Wave Soldering, the early-stage DFM/DFT/DFA review (Design for Manufacturability/Testability/Assembly) is the first line of defense to mitigate risks and reduce costs. If the design phase fails to fully consider the limitations of the soldering process, it will lead to endless quality issues later.

During the review phase, our team focuses on the following key points:

Component Layout and Spacing: The soldering nozzle requires sufficient movement space. A safe distance (typically 3-5 mm) must be maintained between THT components and adjacent SMT components (especially small chip components) to prevent thermal shock or solder bridging during the soldering process.
Thermal Design: Large grounding or power planes act like massive heat sinks, causing insufficient heating of THT pins and resulting in cold solder joints. Through DFM/DFT/DFA review, we recommend using Thermal Relief Pads to ensure solder joints reach the soldering temperature quickly and uniformly.
Testability (DFT): The placement of test points is critical. Test probes require stable and reliable contact points. We ensure test points are kept away from THT solder areas to avoid contamination by flux residues and reserve adequate space for Fixture Design (ICT/FCT) probe press-down.

A comprehensive DFM/DFT/DFA review integrates manufacturing and testing requirements into the design phase, laying a solid foundation for subsequent automated production and efficient testing.

Key DFM Considerations for Selective Wave Soldering

Solder-Free Zones and Shielding: Maintain a 3-5 mm (example) safety distance for nozzle movement and solder mask protection
Thermal Relief Pads: Use Thermal Relief for ground/power plane pins to prevent cold solder joints
Solder Thief and Guidance: Add Solder Thief/drainage zones on long edges to reduce bridging

Via treatment: Vias near pads should be tented or covered with solder mask to prevent solder wicking

Component height and orientation: Arrange pins along wave direction and control bottom component height to fit pallet

Test point planning: Avoid soldering areas and flux paths to facilitate ICT/FPT

Pallet Design Essentials

Material selection: High-temperature resistant composite materials (example), with pockets and seal dams conforming to board surface
Pocket clearance: Maintain 0.3-0.8 mm (example) gap around pins for better wetting and venting
Support and flatness: Add support blocks in critical areas, control warpage, and reduce stress on ICT fixtures
Path and nozzle: Plan single/dual nozzle paths to avoid shadow areas and heat accumulation
Maintainability: Easy-to-clean, residue-proof design; serialized markings for MES traceability

ICT/FCT Testing: Key Points for Coverage and Fixture Design

After soldering, rigorous testing is the only standard to verify quality. In-Circuit Test (ICT) and Functional Test (FCT) are two pillars to ensure the proper functionality of industrial robot control PCBs.

ICT (In-Circuit Test) is primarily used to detect soldering defects such as open circuits, short circuits, wrong components, reversed polarity, etc. For circuit boards processed with Selective wave soldering, ICT testing faces unique challenges. The presence of THT components affects the board's flatness, imposing higher requirements on test fixture design. Professional Fixture design (ICT/FCT) must precisely calculate probe height and pressure to ensure reliable contact with test points without causing mechanical damage to soldered THT components. For small batches or prototyping stages, Flying probe test offers a flexible alternative without expensive fixtures, enabling quick verification of circuit connectivity.

FCT (Functional Test) simulates the PCB's operation in real-world environments to verify compliance with all functional specifications. This includes checking motor drive signals, sensor data reading, real-time performance of communication interfaces (e.g., EtherCAT), etc. A robust FCT solution, combined with precise Fixture design (ICT/FCT), is key to ensuring every shipped high-speed PCB meets the stringent performance criteria of industrial robots.

Core Testing Strategy Points

Test Point Accessibility: Key network probe locations should avoid solder and flux paths.
Fixture Stability: Account for PCB height variations using floating pressure blocks/layered supports for even force distribution.
Flying Probe + Bed of Nails: Use FPT
Diagnostic Accuracy: Programs must distinguish solder joint/component failures with visualizable fault localization.

First Article Inspection (FAI): Validating Process Window and First-Article Quality

Before entering mass production, First Article Inspection (FAI) is an indispensable quality control checkpoint. It comprehensively verifies whether the production process, equipment parameters, materials, and operational methods can consistently yield qualified products meeting design requirements. For Selective Wave Soldering processes, FAI holds particular significance.

During FAI, we conduct destructive and non-destructive analyses on the first few production boards, including:

X-Ray Inspection: Checks THT solder joint fill rate (Hole Fill), voids, and internal defects.
Cross-Sectional Analysis: Vertically sectioned solder joints are microscopically examined to assess wetting angles and intermetallic compound (IMC) layer thickness-key indicators of long-term reliability.
Electrical & Functional Testing: Full ICT and FCT execution ensures 100% compliance with all performance metrics for first articles.

Through rigorous First Article Inspection (FAI), HILPCB identifies optimal soldering parameters (e.g., preheat temperature, soldering duration, nozzle type) and standardizes them into SOPs, establishing a reliable process baseline for subsequent Turnkey PCBA Assembly.

Process Window & Parameters (Example)

Parameter	Typical Range/Practice (Example)	Key Points
Flux	No-clean/water washable type, controlled solid content and spray volume	Avoid residue and cold soldering; ensure spray uniformity
Preheating Top-side	Approx. 90-130°C (example)	Promote solvent evaporation and wetting, prevent condensation
Solder pot temperature	Approx. 250-275°C (example)	Match alloy and substrate, prevent overheating
Contact/dip soldering time	Approx. 1.0-3.0 s (example)	Balance between hole filling and bridging
Nitrogen environment	Low oxygen (e.g., low ppm)	Reduce oxidation, improve wetting, minimize solder balls
Conveyance/peeling	Controlled transport speed and peel angle	Prevent icicles/burrs and shadowing

Note: The above parameters are general examples. Specific windows should be validated and solidified into SOP/MES during FAI based on the alloy system (e.g., SAC305/Sn63Pb37), board thickness/copper thickness/aperture, component thermal capacity, and equipment characteristics. Refer to applicable standards and material/equipment application notes (e.g., IPC J-STD-001, IPC-A-610, etc.).

Get PCB Quote

Conformal Coating: Synergy Between Material Selection and Process Window

Industrial robots often operate in harsh environments, facing challenges such as moisture, dust, and chemical corrosion. Therefore, conformal coating is a necessary measure to ensure the long-term stable operation of control PCBs. The treatment of flux residues after selective wave soldering directly affects the adhesion and protective performance of the coating.

The process requires thorough cleaning of the PCB before coating to remove all ionic and non-ionic contaminants that may affect adhesion. Selective coating is also a challenge, as areas such as connectors typically need to remain exposed. We employ precision automated coating equipment and custom masking fixtures to ensure uniform coating thickness, sharp edges, and perfect coverage of areas requiring protection while avoiding contamination of functional interfaces. This is particularly critical for high-reliability rigid-flex PCBs, as different regions have varying protection requirements.

Cleaning and Conformal Coating: Key Synergies

Ionic contamination: Perform ROSE/ionic contamination assessment (example) after cleaning to reduce residue risks
Material compatibility: Select coating systems compatible with flux to avoid plasticizer/solvent impact
Thickness recommendations (example): Acrylic 25-75 μm, silicone 50-150 μm, with edge anti-piling
Masking and exposure: Mask connectors/pluggable/adjustable areas; selectively coat critical RF/high-speed zones
UV and inspection: UV tracing and thickness sampling, with cross-sectioning if necessary to confirm interface quality

HILPCB Assembly Advantages

One-Stop Service: Provides a complete turnkey solution from PCB manufacturing to component procurement, SMT, THT soldering, testing, and coating.
Process Synergy: Our engineers treat soldering, cleaning, and coating as an integrated workflow to ensure seamless transitions and avoid potential quality risks.
Material Expertise: Recommends the most suitable solder, flux, and conformal coating materials based on your product's application environment, achieving the optimal balance between cost and performance.
Automation & Precision: Utilizes advanced selective wave soldering and automated coating equipment to guarantee consistency and high quality for every PCB.

Consistency and Traceability: The Value of Traceability/MES in Mass Production

For high-value, high-reliability equipment like industrial robots, traceability in the production process is critical. When issues arise in the field, it must be possible to quickly trace back to specific production batches, equipment, operators, or even process parameters. This is where Traceability/MES (Manufacturing Execution System) proves its worth.

On HILPCB's production line, each PCB is assigned a unique QR code. Through the Traceability/MES system, we record all key parameters at the Selective wave soldering station: the batch number of the solder used, the temperature profile during preheating and soldering, the movement speed and path of the nozzle, etc. Similarly, ICT/FCT test data, First Article Inspection (FAI) reports, and coating material batch information are all linked to this QR code.

This end-to-end traceability capability is not only a prerequisite for meeting the quality requirements of high-end clients but also serves as the data foundation for our continuous process improvement and quality analysis. When data indicates fluctuations in the yield of a specific batch, the Traceability/MES system helps us quickly identify the root cause-whether it's a material issue or equipment parameter drift-enabling precise corrective actions.

Defect and Inspection Matrix (Common THT Solder Joint Items)

Defect	Possible Causes	Inspection/Verification
Insufficient hole fill/Cold solder	Insufficient preheating, low alloy temperature, heat dissipation from large copper areas	Visual inspection/cross-section, X-Ray, ICT/FPT connectivity
Bridging/Spiking/Burrs	Excessive contact time, improper peel angle, insufficient solder withdrawal zone	Visual inspection, AOI (THT), functional testing
Solder balls/Splashing	Insufficient flux/solvent volatilization, excessive spraying	Visual inspection, cleanliness (ROSE)

Testing and Evaluation (THT Solder Joints, Example)

Item	Typical Target/Criteria (Example)	Method	Description
Hole fill	≥ 75% (Common Class 3 target, example)	Cross-section/Visual Inspection/X-Ray	Comply with applicable standards (IPC-A-610, etc.)
Wetting Appearance/Fillet	Continuous wetting, solder fillet reaches appropriate height on pins/pads	Visual Inspection/Microscopy	Combined with IMC thickness evaluation (cross-section)
Bridging/Spikes	No bridging, controlled spikes/icicles	Visual Inspection/AOI (THT)	Adjust separation angle and contact time if necessary

In summary, to successfully navigate the manufacturing challenges of industrial robot control PCBs, it is essential to establish a comprehensive quality assurance system centered around Selective wave soldering that spans the entire process from design, testing, verification to mass production. This requires in-depth process knowledge, precise equipment, and robust data management capabilities. From early-stage DFM/DFT/DFA review, through Flying probe test and ICT/FCT fixture design, to final Traceability/MES system support, each step is interconnected, collectively forging the reliable "heart" of industrial robot control systems.